Politics Across the Hudson, Politics Across the Hudson, 0813572495, 0-8135-7249-5, 978-0-8135-7249-9, 9780813572499, , Rivergate Regionals Collection, Politics Across the Hudson, 0813572509, 0-8135-7250-9, 978-0-8135-7250-5, 9780813572505, , Rivergate Regionals Collection, Politics Across the Hudson, 0813572517, 0-8135-7251-7, 978-0-8135-7251-2, 9780813572512, , Rivergate Regionals Collection, Politics Across the Hudson, 0813572525, 0-8135-7252-5, 978-0-8135-7252-9, 9780813572529, , Rivergate Regionals Col
Politics Across the Hudson
The Tappan Zee Megaproject
Philip Mark Plotch
272 pages, 7 maps, 4 diagrams, 14 photos, 6-1/8 x 9-1/4
Series: Rivergate Regionals Collection
Public Policy, New York City and State
Winner of the 2015 American Planning Association New York Metro Chapter Journalism Award
The State of New York is now building one of the world’s longest, widest, and most expensive bridges—the new Tappan Zee Bridge—stretching more than three miles across the Hudson River, approximately thirteen miles north of New York City. In Politics Across the Hudson, urban planner Philip Plotch offers a behind-the-scenes look at three decades of contentious planning and politics centered around this bridge. He reveals valuable lessons for those trying to tackle complex public policies while also confirming our worst fears about government dysfunction.
Drawing on his extensive experience planning megaprojects, interviews with more than a hundred key figures—including governors, agency heads, engineers, civic advocates, and business leaders—and extraordinary access to internal government records, Plotch tells a compelling story of high-stakes battles between powerful players in the public, private, and civic sectors. He reveals how state officials abandoned viable options, squandered hundreds of millions of dollars, forfeited more than three billion dollars in federal funds, and missed out on important opportunities. Faced with the public’s unrealistic expectations, no one could identify a practical solution to a vexing problem, a dilemma that led three governors to study various alternatives rather than disappoint key constituencies.
Politics Across the Hudson continues where Robert Caro’s The Power Broker left off and illuminates the power struggles involved in building New York’s first major new bridge since the Robert Moses era. Plotch describes how one governor, Andrew Cuomo, shrewdly overcame the seemingly insurmountable obstacles of onerous environmental regulations, vehement community opposition, insufficient funding, interagency battles, and overly optimistic expectations.
"Plotch has tremendous insight into the challenges of building extraordinarily complex projects in difficult political and fiscal climates. His professional experience and probing questions have enabled him to help explain Planet Albany—a place where thought defies gravity."
—David A. Paterson, Governor of New York, 2008-2010
"Philip Plotch combines a terrific story with a relentless search for evidence and doses of humor to give us a first-rate portrayal of the political process at work. He recounts the efforts over several decades to replace the aging Tappan Zee Bridge. Through three decades of struggle and failed plans, three governors—George Pataki, Eliot Spitzer, and David Paterson—kept the project alive though often on a 'death watch.' Plotch reveals how Governor Andrew Cuomo picked up the torch, manipulated the facts where he thought it necessary, and overcame many obstacles to begin construction."
—Jameson W. Doig, author of Empire on the Hudson
"We spend years in traffic yet know little of the brew of politics, bureaucracy, interests, and ideals keeping us there. Planner and political scientist Plotch examines this principle through one transportation planning debacle: the three-decade struggle to refurbish or replace the Tappan Zee Bridge across the Hudson River north of New York City ... Anyone concerned about the place of large infrastructure projects in the modern U.S. should consider this sobering case study."
"Philip Plotch's political history about the replacement of New York's Tappan Zee Bridge should be on the bookshelf of planners and other practicioners, elected officials, community members, and students engaged in or entering megaproject and urban politics debates ... Plotch skillfully tells the painful story of this bridge's evolution through a three-decade saga of conflict between elected officials, engineers, planners, environmentalists, and others who held divergent views about addressing traffic congestion in the corridor."
—Journal of the American Planning Association
“The Tappan Zee Bridge has been a symbol of infrastructure inaction in the U.S. over the last several decades – until now! New York State's Governor Cuomo has found the way to overcome the bickering among the many stakeholders and actually get to construction of the much needed replacement for this obsolescent and heavily used structure. How he did it, and how decades of issues stood in the way, are well told by Dr. Philip Plotch. This is a treatise for policy makers, planners, engineers, community leaders. Plotch has brought to light the genius in how to get big things done. It should go on your shelf next to your copy of Caro.”
—Robert E. Paaswell, Distinguished Professor of Civil Engineering (City College of New York) and Dire
“Even with my lifelong interest in traffic congestion, I had much to learn from Politics Across the Hudson. What resonated most with me is the extremely lengthy process of conflicting viewpoints among the many agencies involved in our transportation systems. Nothing gets done fast."
—Anthony Downs, author of Stuck in Traffic
“Plotch’s analytical skills are top-notch and his writing is incisive and succinct. He writes with a historian's attention to detail, a political scientist's interest in theory, and a public policy scholar's fascination with how the sausage is actually made.”
—Jeffrey Smith, assistant professor of Politics and Advocacy, The New School, New York
Philip Plotch gives a brief history and sums up the future of the Tapen Zee Bridge project in this short video
Author / Editor Bio
PHILIP MARK PLOTCH is an assistant professor of political science and director of the Masters in Public Administration program at Saint Peter’s University in Jersey City. He is the former director of World Trade Center Redevelopment and Special Projects for the Lower Manhattan Development Corporation, and the former manager of planning for New York’s Metropolitan Transportation Authority.
Table Of Contents
List of Illustrations
List of Tables
Guides to This Book
1 The I-287 Corridor: From Conception to Congestion
2 Searching for Congestion Solutions (1980–1988)
3 Finalizing Plans for the HOV Lane (1988–1995)
4 Killing the HOV Lane (1994–1997)
5 Permut’s Rail Line and Platt’s Bridge
6 Pataki’s Task Force: Raising Expectations Sky High (1998–2000)
7 The Thruway Authority versus Metro-North (2000–2006)
8 Eliot Spitzer Doesn’t Have Enough Steam (2007–2008)
9 David Paterson: The Overwhelmed Governor (2008–2010)
10 Andrew Cuomo Takes Charge in 2011
11 Public Reaction and Cuomo’s Campaign (2011–2012)
12 Lost Opportunities and Wasted Resources